Tuesday, May 4, 2021

Jan Nolte, April 21, 2021, Libya

German Bundestag, Plenarprotokoll 19/223, pp. 28325-28326.

Right honorable Frau President. Right honorable ladies and gentlemen.

Lately, there was for once gladdening news from Libya. A government of national unity has been formed and this shall conduct elections on December 24. It can only be truly hoped that it also succeeds and nothing intervenes. And yes, the diplomatic efforts of the Federal government have had their part therein.

Operation Irini, however, on which we speak today, does not have the potential to make a substantial contribution to the improvement of the situation in Libya; we have distinctly seen it in the last year. We simply have no means of searching ships if the nation of the ship’s flag refuses. Thus no weapons smuggler can be arrested. Operation Irini thus becomes a largely symbolic mission. Could we arrest the weapons smuggler, it would besides work out very asymmetrically, essentially into a party to a conflict.Yet we cannot do it. Operation Irini is a toothless tiger. In addition exists the potential that Operation Irini becomes a pull factor for illegal migration, with all negative accompanying aspects. On that account, we will reject it today.  

The principle which one wants to employ here is the principle of naming and shaming. One wants to name and expose before the world public anyone who brings weapons to Libya. Yet here we again arrive at what I have already addressed: If a ship is not boarded so as to establish that weapons were being smuggled, then naturally there is also no basis for naming a weapons smuggler before the world public. The entire initiative of naming and shaming naturally does not function.

This was nevertheless tested a bit with Erdogan. Because he has refused searches of his ships, one has nevertheless attempted to employ the principle of naming and shaming. Yet let us look at the past year. Does anyone have the impression that Erdogan ate humble pie [kleine Brötchen gebacken] or in any way had been intimidated? I do not have the impression. He has behaved aggressively towards Greece, he has behaved aggressively towards France, and when the EU Commission President was with him, he off-handedly set her in the farthest corner of his sofa and acted not especially abashed.

Thus, this initiative does not function. Despite this, we must naturally remain in Libya; since it is not clear that the peace holds. Khalifa Haftar is not represented in the new government, as he had desired, and the Libyan army announces that weapons from Egypt have been delivered to him. Yet – I have already said it many times – Operation Irini is here not the right tool. Here, one must continue to be active diplomatically, to speak with the actors, not only within Libya; the previous speaker has plainly addressed this. There are states outside Libya which have interests in Libya, which deliver weapons. We finally need, certainly in relation to the weapons deliveries to General Haftar, a means of stopping this, and naturally the mercenaries must be withdrawn from Libya.

For a corresponding diplomatic proceeding, the Federal government also has the support of the AfD. But not for this mission, which is a toothless tiger and in which is contained the potential of developing into a pull factor.

 

[trans: tem]