Monday, November 16, 2026

Michael Kaufmann, October 15, 2026, Research and Espionage

German Bundestag, Plenarprotokoll 21/102, pp. 12934-12935.

Honored President. Esteemed colleagues. Right honorable citizens.  
In 1995, the Constitution Protection in its report introduced for the  
first time its own sub-chapter for technology transfer controlled by  
intelligence service. The central point, then as today: The People’s  
Republic of China. Yet in view of this threat, not a single thing came  
from government beyond the development of handouts and offers to  
consult. Obligatory and really sharp measures against the theft of our  
research results have, as before, not been struck – thus: A nil return. 
Let us speak in clear text: German businesses and research facilities  
were for decades robbed, systematically and state-organized. Now  
shall the national platform for research security correct that. 

Joachim Ebmeyer (CDU/CSU): Precisely!

Yet even here applies only the well-known formula “coordinate,  
inform, consult” – everything voluntary, nothing compulsory.  
This naïve attitude endangers our prosperity and the national  
security. That is irresponsible. 

The consequences of this hair-raising cluelessness are lately  
shown at the Helmholtz Center for Research Security. There  
where our cyber-security is researched, according to the minister’s  
statements, "the floodgates stand wide open”. We thus need reckon  
that research results reached institutes in China which have been  
strictly sanctioned by the U.S.A.. In that regard, we know that since  
2017 every citizen in China is legally obligated to cooperate with  
the intelligence services. 

In view of this, who sets up only voluntarism and consultation  
manages an organized denial of reality.  

Till Steffen (Greens): That which the AfD does voluntarily! 

States like the U.S.A. or Canada have understood that an open  
scientific system can only be protected if clear rules are set up and  
enforced. Research security is not a contradiction of the freedom  
of science. 

Till Steffen (Greens): …but for the AfD’s policy!

It is its guaranty of survival. We thus orient with our motion  
[Durchsache 21/554] and demand among other things: 
First. Who lays claim to the Bund’s research means needs to  
regularly publish conflicts of interest, side activities and respective  
foreign financing. 

Filiz Polat (Greens): Do that for once!

Second: Security concepts are not non-compulsory 
recommendations. They need be a strong and investigative 
prerequisite for promotion of security and economic projects. 
 
Nicole Höchst (AfD): So it is!

Third. Guest scientists and students from states under suspicion  
of managing espionage against our key technologies need to go  
through a deepened security examination.

Till Steffen (Greens): Have you spoken with Herr Krah? 
That’s an important question! You had a perpetrator in 
your delegation! You should speak with Herr Krah about 
that! I believe that will be an interesting talk!

 We require obligatory and effectively preventative rules for 
protection of our research.

Vice-president Bodo Ramelow: Herr member.

Let’s make Germany strong again!

Sonja Lemke (Linke): Which “again”?

[trans: tem]